ROC BENGALURU IMPOSED PENALTY ON TACTILE EDUCATION SERVICES PRIVATE LIMITED FOR CONVERSION OF LOAN INTO EQUITY WITHOUT PASSING SPECIAL RESOLUTION AND THE ALLOTMENT WAS INCORRECTLY REPORTED AS A RIGHTS ISSUE UNDER SECTION 62(1)(A).
ROC , BENGALURU VS ON TACTILE EDUCATION SERVICES PRIVATE LIMITED
FACTS OF THE CASE
CONVERSION OF LOAN INTO EQUITY WITHOUT PASSING SPECIAL RESOLUTION AND THE
ALLOTMENT WAS INCORRECTLY REPORTED AS A RIGHTS ISSUE UNDER SECTION 62(1)(A) WHEREAS
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN TREATED AS A PREFERENTIAL ALLOTMENT UNDER SECTION 62(1)(C)
INVOLVING CONSIDERATION OTHER THAN CASH.
VIOLATION:
·
Converted
loans from shareholders/directors into equity shares without prior approval via
special resolution under Section 62(3).
·
Incorrectly
reported the allotment as a rights issue under Section 62(1)(a) instead of a
preferential allotment under Section 62(1)(c).
·
This
triggered non-compliance with Section 42 (private placement provisions).
REDUCED PENALTY DUE TO START UP
• ₹2 lakh on the company.
• ₹1 lakh each on directors Ravi Rangan Srinivasa,
Aragudige Prabhakara Raghu, and Rajani Rangan.
• Reduced penalties applied under Section
446B (benefits for start-ups).
RISKS & COMPLIANCE LESSONS
·
Misclassification
of allotment (rights issue vs. preferential allotment) can lead to serious penalties.
· Special resolution is mandatory before converting loans into equity.
·
Private
placement rules under Section 42 must be strictly followed, including filing
Form PAS-3 within 15 days.
·
Start-ups
may receive reduced penalties under Section 446B, but violations still attract
fines and reputational risk.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
·
Always pass
a special resolution before converting loans into equity.
·
Ensure
allotments are correctly categorized (rights issue vs. preferential allotment).
·
File PAS-3
on time to avoid additional penalties.
·
Seek legal
and compliance review before restructuring capital.
·
Start-ups
should leverage Section 446B relief, but not rely on it as a safeguard against
non-compliance.
# YOUR
COMPLIANCE PARTNER R V SECKAR, FCS, LLB 79047 19295,






