Followers of my Blog

Wednesday, April 1, 2026

NEW CHAIRMAN , COMPANY SECRETARY WHO NEVER LEFT - CORPORATE GOVERNANCE RED FLAGS AT SUNDARAM CLAYTON LTD

 NEW CHAIRMAN , COMPANY SECRETARY WHO NEVER LEFT - CORPORATE GOVERNANCE RED FLAGS AT SUNDARAM CLAYTON LTD


"72-HOUR U-TURN"

The corporate governance story at Sundaram Clayton Limited involves a rapid "72-hour U-turn" in March 2026, where the company abruptly reversed high-level resignations and leadership changes.

INITIAL EXIT (MARCH 27, 2026):

The board initially accepted the resignation of P.D. Dev Kishan, the long-standing Company Secretary and Compliance Officer, effective April 5, 2026, citing "personal reasons".

NEW APPOINTMENT:

At the same meeting, M. Muthulakshmi was appointed to succeed him starting April 6, 2026.

SUDDEN REVERSAL (MARCH 30, 2026):

Only three days later, in a meeting convened with less than 24 hours' notice, the board rescinded these decisions.

·      P.D. Dev Kishan withdrew his resignation and will continue in his role with "no break in service".

·      M. Muthulakshmi's appointment was cancelled.

THE "NEW" CHAIR: VENU SRINIVASAN'S RETURN

TRANSITION REVERSAL:

Retired bureaucrat R. Gopalan, who had been appointed Chairman in 2022 to professionalize leadership, stepped down from the role with immediate effect.

SRINIVASAN BACK AT HELM:

Venu Srinivasan, previously Chairman Emeritus, was redesignated as Chairman and Managing Director.

GOPALAN'S ROLE:

He remains on the board as a Non-Executive Independent Director.

CORPORATE GOVERNANCE CONTEXT

Succession Questions: These moves reversed a "textbook" transition plan from 2022 that had placed professional managers and the next generation, like Managing Director Lakshmi Venu, in key roles.

REPORTING FRICTION:

 Reports suggest internal concerns regarding the reporting structure.

Lakshmi Venu reportedly questioned why the Company Secretary (Kishan) was not a full-time employee and why he reported to the CFO of TVS Holdings instead of directly to her.

New SEBI regulations (Regulation 6) recently clarified that a Compliance Officer should report no more than one level below the Board or Managing Director to ensure independence.

CEO CHURN:

These changes occurred alongside the resignation of CEO Vivek S. Joshi (effective March 31) and the appointment of R. Venkatesh as the new CEO starting April 1, 2026.

GOVERNANCE RED FLAGS:

·      Continuity without accountability can dilute the intent of leadership change

·      Perception risks: Stakeholders may question independence and internal controls

·      Board oversight gaps if key managerial personnel remain unexamined

KEY TAKEAWAY:

·      A new Chair alone cannot reset governance culture. True reform requires:

·      Re-evaluation of Key Managerial Personnel (KMP)

·      Strengthening independence in compliance functions

·      Clear signaling of accountability across all governance layers

THE LARGER LESSON:

Corporate governance is not about who leads, but how systems function. Without aligning both, even well-intended leadership changes risk becoming cosmetic.

This episode highlights how corporate governance in family-led conglomerates often blends tradition with rapid adjustments to maintain stability.

 

# YOUR COMPLIANCE PARTNER R V SECKAR, FCS, LLB 79047 19295,

Tuesday, March 31, 2026

FORM MR-1 HAS BEEN FILED WITH DELAY OF 41 DAYS PROBABLY WITH ADDITIONAL FEES. STILL THE COMPANY IS PUNISHABLE BY ROC?

 FORM MR-1 HAS BEEN FILED WITH DELAY OF 41 DAYS PROBABLY WITH ADDITIONAL FEES. STILL THE COMPANY IS PUNISHABLE BY ROC?

MCA CRACKS DOWN ON DELAY IN FORM MR-1 FILING

GARUDA AEROSPACE LIMITED VS ROC, CHENNAI

In a recent adjudication, the Registrar of Companies, Chennai imposed penalties on Garuda Aerospace Limited for delay in filing Form MR-1, reinforcing the strict compliance stance under the Companies Act, 2013.

 WHAT WAS THE ISSUE?

The company filed Form MR-1 (return of appointment of managerial personnel) 41 days beyond the prescribed 60-day timeline.

ROC’s POSITION:

The authority made it clear that:

·      Statutory timelines are mandatory in nature

·      Inadvertence or internal lapses do not constitute a valid defense

FORM MR-1 HAS BEEN FILED WITH DELAY OF 41 DAYS PROBABLY WITH ADDITIONAL FEES. STILL THE COMPANY IS PUNISHABLE BY ROC?

Under Section 196(4) of the Companies Act, 2013, every company must file Form MR-1 within 60 days of appointment of a managerial person.

KEY POINT

Additional fee = procedural compliance

Penalty = consequence of statutory violation

These operate independently.

WHY PENALTY MAY STILL APPLY?

The Registrar of Companies (ROC) treats delayed filing as a default, even if:

·      The form is eventually filed, and additional fees are paid.

·      Late filing means the company failed to comply within the prescribed timeline, triggering penal provisions under:

PENALTY IMPOSED:

COMPANY:

₹51,000

OFFICERS IN DEFAULT:

₹50,000 each ( On Two directors)

 LEGAL BACKING:

Action taken under Section 196 read with Section 454 of the Companies Act, 2013.

KEY TAKEAWAYS FOR PROFESSIONALS & COMPANIES:

✔️ Timely filing of MR-1 is non-negotiable

✔️ Even short delays can result in financial exposure

✔️ Personal liability of directors/KMPs is real and enforceable

✔️ Robust compliance tracking systems are essential

COMPLIANCE INSIGHT:

This case reiterates MCA’s increasing reliance on strict, system-driven enforcement, leaving little room for procedural laxity.

#YOUR COMPLIANCE PARTNER – R V - SECKAR , FCS, LLB 79047 19295,

Monday, March 30, 2026

PENALTY ON SECRETARIAL AUDITOR ₹2,00,000 (TWO LAKHS) FOR CRITICAL REPORTING FAILURES IN THE SECRETARIAL AUDIT REPORT.

 PENALTY ON SECRETARIAL AUDITOR ₹2,00,000 (TWO LAKHS) FOR CRITICAL REPORTING FAILURES IN THE SECRETARIAL AUDIT REPORT.


ESSAR SHIPPING LTD VS ROC GUJARAT PENALTY ON SECRETARIAL AUDITOR

The Registrar of Companies (ROC), Gujarat, imposed a penalty of ₹2,00,000 (Two Lakhs) on the Secretarial Auditor of Essar Shipping Limited for violating Section 204 of the Companies Act, 2013. The order, dated May 18, 2023, followed an inspection that revealed critical reporting failures in the Secretarial Audit Report.

KEY FINDINGS OF THE VIOLATION

The inspection, ordered by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), identified that the Secretarial Auditor failed to report the following in the audit report for the financial year ended March 31, 2019:

SECTION 186 NON-COMPLIANCE:

The auditor did not mention the company's failure to comply with provisions regarding loans and investments by the company.

 

SECRETARIAL STANDARDS:

The auditor failed to report that the Minutes Books for Board Meetings and Audit Committee meetings were not maintained in accordance with the Secretarial Standards issued by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India (ICSI).

PENALTY DETAILS

Imposed On: The Practicing Company Secretary (PCS) acting as the Secretarial Auditor.

Amount: ₹2,00,000, which is the maximum penalty prescribed under Section 204(4) for such contraventions.

Adjudication Process: The Secretarial Auditor's representative argued that the company had no operations and was in loss, claiming the omissions were "inadvertent errors" with no unfair gain. However, the Adjudicating Officer held that professional diligence is mandatory and imposed the penalty.

SIGNIFICANCE

This case is considered a landmark "eye-opener" for professionals, as it reinforces that Secretarial Auditors are held strictly accountable for ensuring all regulatory non-compliances are qualified in their reports, regardless of the company's operational status.

#YOUR COMPLIANCE PARTNER – R V - SECKAR , FCS, LLB 79047 19295,

Sunday, March 29, 2026

VIJAYPAT SINGHANIA FOUNDER OF RAYMOND LTD SAYS HIS SON GAUTAM HAS REDUCED HIM TO HAND-TO-MOUTH LIFE

 VIJAYPAT SINGHANIA  FOUNDER OF RAYMOND LTD SAYS HIS SON GAUTAM HAS REDUCED HIM TO HAND-TO-MOUTH LIFE

Dr Vijaypat Singhania, who built Raymond Ltd into one of the largest apparel brands in the country

Ex-tycoon’s lawyer alleges his client’s simple perks such as a car and a driver have been withdrawn and payment of rent to an alternate accommodation withheld.

·       Dr. Vijaypat Singhania is locked in a legal battle with Raymond, a firm he helped build.

·       He alleges that his son, Gautam Singhania, has forced him to live a hand-to-mouth existence.

·       The retired tycoon claims he is struggling financially

·       He gave away a substantial portion of his wealth and ownership in the company to his son.

·       Subsequently, he alleged that he was not provided adequate financial support.

·       He has stated that he now lives in a rented apartment in Mumbai.

·       He has also been involved in legal disputes with his son over property and maintenance.

This case study reinforces

·       Family business succession planning

·       Estate transfer without safeguards

YOUR COMPLIANCE PARTNER – R V SECKAR FCS, LLB 79047 19295

Saturday, March 28, 2026

NO SINGLE WOMAN DIRECTOR IN 179 GOVERNMENT-OWNED COMPANIES, PUBLIC SECTOR ENTERPRISES- COMPANY LAW VIOLATION BY PUBLIC SECTOR COMPANIES

 NO SINGLE WOMAN DIRECTOR IN 179 GOVERNMENT-OWNED COMPANIES, PUBLIC SECTOR ENTERPRISES- COMPANY LAW VIOLATION BY PUBLIC SECTOR COMPANIES


NO SINGLE WOMAN DIRECTOR ON THEIR BOARDS IN 179 STATE-OWNED COMPANIES

A significant number of government companies are failing to meet legal requirements. As many as 179 state-owned companies including Public Sector Enterprises, do not have a single woman director on their boards.

This non-compliance affects companies that are required to have at least one woman director under the Companies Act.

REQUIREMENT UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT ,2013

Under Section 149(1) of the Companies Act, 2013, read with Rule 3 of the Companies (Appointment and Qualification of Directors) Rules, 2014, certain classes of companies are mandatorily required to appoint at least one woman director, including:

  • ·      Listed companies
  • ·Public companies meeting prescribed capital/turnover thresholds

·      Additionally, for listed PSUs, the requirement is reinforced under SEBI (LODR) Regulations, 2015, which mandates:

At least one woman director, and

For top entities, at least one independent woman director

Every listed company and every other public company having paid-up share capital of Rs 100 crore or more or having a turnover of Rs 300 crore or more is required to appoint at least one woman director on its board.

GOVERNANCE IMPLICATIONS

Failure to appoint a woman director is not merely a technical lapse—it reflects:

·      Weak board diversity practices

·      Non-alignment with ESG norms (especially “Social” and “Governance” pillars)

·      Regulatory non-compliance risk, including penalties

GENDER DIVERSITY IN BOARDROOMS

It also contradicts the policy intent of improving gender diversity in boardrooms, especially in public sector undertakings that are expected to set governance benchmarks

WHY REGISTRAR OF COMPANIES ARE RELUCTANT TO INITIATE ACTION AGAINST 179 PUBLIC SECTOR ENTERPRISES?

The jurisdictional Registrar of Companies (ROC) under the Ministry of Corporate Affairs can:

·      Initiate adjudication proceedings

·      Impose penalties on the company and officers in default

In listed PSUs, Securities and Exchange Board of India may:

  • ·      Levy fines
  • ·      Freeze promoter shareholding (in extreme cases of prolonged non-compliance)

WHY 74 WOMEN MPs IN THE PARLIAMENT HAVE NOT RAISED THEIR VOICES FOR NON-APPOINTMENT OF WOMEN DIRECTORS ?

As of June 2024, there are 74 women MPs elected to the 18th Lok Sabha, accounting for approximately 13.6% of the total 543 seats.

It is shocking to note that even a single women MP has raised their voices in the Parliament for these violations.

WHY THIS HAPPENS IN PSUS?

This issue is particularly prevalent in government-owned entities due to:

·      Delays in appointments by administrative ministries

·      Vacancies pending ACC (Appointments Committee of the Cabinet) approvals

·      Over-reliance on government nomination processes rather than independent search mechanisms

STRATEGIC TAKEAWAY

For compliance officers and board advisors:

·      Ensure continuous board composition monitoring

·      Maintain a pipeline of eligible woman candidates

·      Trigger early escalation to administrative ministries in case of PSU vacancies

·      Document compliance efforts to mitigate liability exposure.

#YOUR COMPLIANCE PARTNER – R V - SECKAR , FCS, LLB 79047 19295,


Friday, March 27, 2026

COMPANY CANNOT CLAIM EXCUSE FOR NON FUNCTIONING OF MCA SITE FOR FILING FORM PAS-3 AND FORM SH-7

 COMPANY CANNOT CLAIM EXCUSE FOR NON FUNCTIONING OF MCA SITE FOR FILING FORM PAS-3 AND FORM SH-7


ROC –CHENNAI VS JAYAPRIYA GRAMA VALARCHI NIDHI LIMITED

FORM PAS-3 AND FORM SH-7

The ROC (Registrar of Companies), Chennai, ruled that Jayapriya Grama Valarchi Nidhi Limited cannot claim the non-functioning of the MCA portal as an excuse for failing to file Form PAS-3 and Form SH-7.

TECHNICAL GLITCHES

The company and its Managing Director were penalized heavily, reinforcing that statutory compliance deadlines must be met regardless of technical glitches. 

PENALTIES IMPOSED

FORM

VIOLATION

PENALTY ON COMPANY

PENALTY ON MANAGING DIRECTOR

PAS-3

Non-filing after increase in paid-up capital

₹1,00,000

₹1,00,000

SH-7

Non-filing after increase in authorized share capital

₹2,57,000

₹1,00,000

KEY LEGAL TAKEAWAYS

SECTION 454, COMPANIES ACT, 2013

Adjudicating authority can impose penalties for non-compliance.

SECTION 64(1), COMPANIES ACT, 2013

Requires filing SH-7 for changes in authorized share capital.

NO EXCUSE PRINCIPLE

Technical glitches or portal downtime do not absolve companies of responsibility.

 

ACTIONABLE GUIDANCE FOR COMPANIES

•     File Early: Avoid last-minute filings to reduce risk of portal downtime

·      Seek Professional Help: Engage company secretaries or compliance experts for timely filings.

APPEAL

Appeal against this order may be filed in writing with the Regional Director, RD Chennai within a period of sixty days from the date of receipt of this order, in Form ADJ setting for the grounds of appeal.

#YOUR COMPLIANCE PARTNER – R V - SECKAR , FCS, LLB 79047 19295

Thursday, March 26, 2026

MANDATORY ROTATION OF DIRECTORS- NON-COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 152(6)- ROC PENALISED FUSION FINANCE LTD RS 4 LACS

 MANDATORY ROTATION OF DIRECTORS- NON-COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 152(6)- ROC PENALISED FUSION FINANCE LTD RS 4 LACS



ROC , NEW DELHI VS FUSION FINANCE LIMITED

SECTION 152(6) OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 2013 MANDATES:

·      At least 2/3rd of total directors of a public company shall be liable to retire by rotation

·      Such rotational directors must be non-independent directors

·      Ensures periodic shareholder control over board composition

VIOLATION DETAILS

PERIOD OF DEFAULT

20 July 2021 – 08 July 2023

REQUIREMENT

Minimum 3 non-independent directors liable to retire by rotation

 

ACTUAL

 

Only 1 rotational director was designated

RESULT

Non-compliance with Section 152(6) for 2 years

PENALTY IMPOSED

Person

Penalty

Company

₹3,00,000

Total

₹4,00,000

KEY OBSERVATIONS BY ROC

STRICT LIABILITY NATURE

 

Non-maintenance of board composition = direct violation

INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS

NOT held liable

Only those in charge of compliance treated as “officer in default”

NATURE OF PENALTY

Continuous default aggravates penalty exposure

OFFICER IN DEFAULT LIABILITY

 

·      Managing Director held personally liable

·      Reinforces Section 2(60) accountability


KEY TAKEAWAYS

This case reinforces that:

·      Board structure compliance is a substantive obligation, not a formality.

·      Increased scrutiny of governance lapses.

·      No leniency even if default is later rectified.


YOUR COMPLIANCE PARTNER – R V - SECKAR , FCS, LLB 79047 19295